Legal Blog: 120 day Statutory Period for filing Written Statement 'Mandatory' under the Commercial Courts Act: Supreme Court Holds

Legal Blog on the Social Networks

Loading

Tuesday, February 19, 2019

120 day Statutory Period for filing Written Statement 'Mandatory' under the Commercial Courts Act: Supreme Court Holds

(Justice Nariman (Left) and Justice Saran (Right)
Hon'ble Judges, Supreme Court of India
A bench of Justice Nariman and Justice Saran of the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held in SCG Contracts India P. Ltd. v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure P. Ltd. that the provisions of Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015 with regard to filing of written statements within 120 days from date of service of summons is mandatory and any delay beyond 120 days cannot be condoned by the Court. While holding so, the bench observed as under:

8) The Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015 came into force on 23.10.2015 bringing in their wake certain amendments to the Code of Civil Procedure. In Order V, Rule 1, sub-rule (1), for the second proviso, the following proviso was substituted:

“Provided further that where the defendant fails to file the written statement within the said period of thirty days, he shall be allowed to file the written statement on such other days, as may be specified by the Court, for reasons to be recorded in writing and on payment of such costs as the court deems fit, but which shall not be later than one hundred twenty days from the date of service of summons and on expiry of one hundred and twenty days from the date of service of summons, the defendant shall forfeit the right to file the written statement and the court shall not allow the written statement to be taken on record.” Equally, in Order VIII Rule 1, a new proviso was substituted as follows:

“Provided that where the defendant fails to file the written statement within the said period of thirty days, he shall be allowed to file the written statement on such other day, as may be specified by the court, for reasons to be recorded in writing and on payment of such costs as the Court deems fit, but which shall not be later than one hundred and twenty days from the date of service of summons and on expiry of one hundred and twenty days from the date of service of summons, the defendant shall forfeit the right to file the written statement and the court shall not allow the written statement to be taken on record.” This was re-emphasized by re-inserting yet another proviso in Order VIII Rule 10 CPC, which reads as under:-

“Procedure when party fails to present written statement called for by Court.- Where any party from whom a written statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9 fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed by the Court, as the case may be, the Court shall pronounce judgment against him, or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit and on pronouncement of such judgment a decree shall be drawn up.
Provided further that no Court shall make an order to extend the time provided under Rule 1 of this Order for filing of the written statement.” A perusal of these provisions would show that ordinarily a written statement is to be filed within a period of 30 days.

However, grace period of a further 90 days is granted which the Court may employ for reasons to be recorded in writing and payment of such costs as it deems fit to allow such written statement to come on record. What is of great importance is the fact that beyond 120 days from the date of service of summons, the defendant shall forfeit the right to file the written statement and the Court shall not allow the written statement to be taken on record. This is further buttressed by the proviso in Order VIII Rule 10 also adding that the Court has no further power to extend the time beyond this period of 120 days.

9) In Bihar Rajya Bhumi Vikas Bank Samiti (supra), a question was raised as to whether Section 34(5)of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, inserted by Amending Act 3 of 2016 is mandatory or directory. In para 11 of the said judgment, this Court referred to Kailash vs. Nanhku, (2005) 4 SCC 480 referring to the text of Order 8 Rule 1 as it stood pre the amendment made by the Commercial Courts Act. It also referred to the Salem Advocate Bar Association vs. Union of India, (2005) 6 SCC 344, which, like the Kailash judgment, held that the mere expression “shall” in Order 8 Rule 1 would not make the provision mandatory. This Court then went on to discuss in para 17 State vs. N.S. Gnaneswaran, (2013) 3 SCC 594 in which Section 154(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure was held to be directory inasmuch as no consequence was provided if the Section was breached. In para 22 by way of contrast to Section 34, Section 29-A of the Arbitration Act was set out. This Court then noted in para 23 as under:

“23. It will be seen from this provision that, unlike Sections 34(5) and (6), if an award is made beyond the stipulated or extended period contained in the section, the consequence of the mandate of the arbitrator being terminated is expressly provided. This provision is in stark contrast to Sections 34(5) and (6) where, as has been stated hereinabove, if the period for deciding the application under Section 34 has elapsed, no consequence is provided. This is one more indicator that the same Amendment Act, when it provided time periods in different situations, did so intending different consequences.”

10) Several High Court judgments on the amended Order VIII Rule 1 have now held that given the consequence of non-filing of written statement, the amended provisions of the CPC will have to be held to be mandatory. [See Oku Tech Private Limited vs. Sangeet Agarwal & Ors. by a learned Single Judge of the Delhi High Court dated 11.08.2016 in CS (OS) No. 3390/2015 as followed by several other judgments including a judgment of the Delhi High Court in Maja Cosmetics vs. Oasis Commercial Pvt. Ltd. 2018 SCC Online Del 6698.

11) We are of the view that the view taken by the Delhi High Court in these judgments is correct in view of the fact that the consequence of forfeiting a right to file the written statement; non-extension of any further time; and the fact that the Court shall not allow the written statement to be taken on record all points to the fact that the earlier law on Order VIII Rule 1 on the filing of written statement underOrder VIII Rule 1 has now been set at naught.

12) However, learned counsel appearing for the respondents relied strongly upon the judgment in Bhanu Kumar Jain (supra) and Shaikh Salim Haji Abdul Khayumsab (supra) and, in particular, paras 22 and 27 of the first judgment and paras 4 & 19 of the second judgment.

13) We are of the view that since both these judgments dealt with the pre-amendment position, they would not be of any direct reliance insofar as the facts of the present case is concerned.

14) Learned counsel appearing for the respondents also relied upon R.K. Roja vs. U.S. Rayudu and Another (supra) for the proposition that the defendant is entitled to file an application for rejection of plaint under Order VII Rule 11 before filing his written statement. We are of the view that this judgment cannot be read in the manner sought for by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents. Order VII Rule 11 proceedings are independent of the filing of a written statement once a suit has been filed. In fact, para 6 of that judgment records “However, we may hasten to add that the liberty to file an application for rejection under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC cannot be made as a ruse for retrieving the lost opportunity to file the written statement”.

15) Learned counsel appearing for the respondents then argued that it cannot be assumed that the learned Single Judge did not know about these amendments when he passed the first impugned order dated 05.12.2017. We do not wish to enter upon this speculative arena. He then argued that since this judgment permitted him to file the written statement beyond 120 days, it was an act of the Court which should prejudice no man. This doctrine cannot be used when the res is not yet judicata. The 05.12.2017 order is res sub judice inasmuch as its correctness has been challenged before us.

16) Learned counsel for the respondents then strongly relied upon the inherent powers of the Court to state that, in any case, a procedural provision such as contained in the amendment, which may lead to unjust consequences can always, in the facts of a given case, be ignored where such unjust consequences follow, as in the facts of the present case. We are again of the view that this argument has also no legs to stand on, given the judgment of this Court in Manohar Lal Chopra vs. Rai Bahadur Rao Raja Seth Hiralal, [1962] Suppl 1 SCR 450. In this judgment, the Court held:
“The suit at Indore which had been instituted later, could be stayed in view of s.10 of the Code. The provisions of that section are clear, definite and mandatory. A Court in which a subsequent suit has been filed is prohibited from proceeding with the trial of that suit in certain specified circumstances.

When there is a special provision in the Code of Civil Procedure for dealing with the contingencies of two such suits being instituted, recourse to the inherent powers under s.151 is not justified...” (at page 470) Clearly, the clear, definite and mandatory provisions of Order V read with Order VIII Rule 1 and 10 cannot be circumvented by recourse to the inherent power under Section 151 to do the opposite of what is stated therein.

17) Clearly, therefore, the 05.12.2017 order which applies in the face of the amendments made to the Civil Procedure Code cannot be sustained. When we come to the second order dated 24.09.2019, the only reason for this order is that 05.12.2017 has attained finality.

18) Factually speaking, this is not correct as a Special Leave Petition from the said order has been filed. Even otherwise, this Court in Canara Bank vs. N.G. Subbaraya Setty and Anr. (supra) has held (page 3414):

“(ii) An issue of law which arises between the same parties in a subsequent suit or proceeding is not res judicata if, by an erroneous decision given on a statutory prohibition in the former suit or proceeding, the statutory prohibition is not given effect to. This is despite the fact that the matter in issue between the parties may be the same as that directly and substantially in issue in the previous suit or proceeding. This is for the reason that in such cases, the rights of the parties are not the only matter for consideration (as is the case of an erroneous interpretation of a statute inter parties), as the public policy contained in the statutory prohibition cannot be set at naught.

This is for the same reason as that contained in matters which pertain to issues of law that raise jurisdictional questions. We have seen how, in Natraj Studios (AIR 1981 SC 537) (supra), it is the public policy of the statutory prohibition contained in Section 28 of the Bombay Rent Act that has to be given effect to. Likewise, the public policy contained in other statutory prohibitions, which need not necessarily go to jurisdiction of a Court, must equally be given effect to, as otherwise special principles of law are fastened upon parties when special considerations relating to public policy mandate that this cannot be done.” The aforesaid para applies on all fours to the facts of the present case, as even assuming that the 05.12.2017 order is final, res judicata cannot stand in the way of an erroneous interpretation of a statutory prohibition. The present is one such case. Therefore, the second order must also be set aside.

53 comments:

  1. Thank you! I hope to hear more updates from you. It's very helpful for me.
    instagram search

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have to point out my love for your kindness in support of those who that should have helped with this concern. Your own keenness to passing the result across was very useful and has surely allowed guys and women just like me to achieve their aim. Your wonderful report implies a great deal a person like me and rather more to my mates. I happen to be writing to make you know what a cool skill my cousin’s princess undergone visiting your site. She learned so many pieces, not to mention what it’s like to possess a very effective helping heart to make others with ease fully know various grueling issues. You really surpassed people have likely results. I really like what you've got no genetic here, certainly like what you’re stating and the way in which you say it. You make it pleasing and you go on to beware of to stay it wise. I cannot wait to scan way more from you. A lot of times it’s great to urge that “perfect balance” between user openness and visual charm. I must say that you have done a good job with this. Needed to write you this very little remark to help give thanks the moment again for your pretty methods you have contribute in this article. It is quite really open-handed of you to deliver easily just what a few persons would have made available for an ebook to earn some dough for themselves, notably in view of the real fact that you simply may need tried it if you needed. These tips as well worked to be the great way to be aware that many people have the same dreams the same as my own to find out very much more around this problem. I am certain there are some more fun occasions up front for those who read your blog. Your personal dedication to passing the solution all over was really helpful and has surely made ladies much like me to achieve their goals. The vital guide entails a lot a person like me and extremely more to my fellow workers.

    ReplyDelete
  3. his can be one particular of the most useful blogs Starting a blog can help you find those people and share your opinions and thoughts.Thanks for your page! Your share information it helped me a lot!This is extremely helpful info!! Very good work.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The article is very good, I like it very much.Here I learned a lot, then I will pay more attention to you.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am impressed by the quality of information on this website .

    ReplyDelete

  6. Great information you got here. I've been reading about this topic. I found it here in your blog. I had a great time reading this.
    http://www.freelegalhelpline

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great post like this must be highly recommended. It is so nice to read such wonderful blog. Thanks for sharing! Have a pleasant day ahead.
    roadaccidentclaimsnetwork

    ReplyDelete
  8. Lawyers need to be good to every person, hire some great lawyers on https://www.advoknit.com/

    ReplyDelete
  9. I’ve just read your post and I can certainly say that it is very informative. It's very helpful for me Thanks.

    https://www.advocatefriend.com/2019/04/importance-of-a-written-statement-in-civil-suit_18.html
    I’ll definitely be sharing this post with my readers and others!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I enjoyed over read your blog post. Your blog have nice information, I got good ideas from this amazing blog.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I’ve just read your post and I can certainly say that it is very informative. It's very helpful for me Thanks.

    https://www.advocatefriend.com/2019/04/importance-written-statement-civil-suit18.html
    I’ll definitely be sharing this post with my readers and others!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Brick and Mortar stores are the back bone of the business industry so you can imaging how crucial communication is for them not just amongst themselves but as well as with customers. Text blasts have now become a daily routine to promote different products and services according to the weather, notable events, season and demand.

    ReplyDelete

  13. Great post ! I am pretty much pleased with your good post.You put really very helpful information

    โปรโมชั่นGclub ของทางทีมงานตอนนี้แจกฟรีโบนัส 50%
    เพียงแค่คุณสมัคร Gclub กับทางทีมงานของเราเพียงเท่านั้น
    ร่วมมาเป็นส่วนหนึ่งกับเว็บไซต์คาสิโนออนไลน์ของเราได้เลยค่ะ
    สมัครสล็อตออนไลน์ >>> goldenslot
    สนใจร่วมลงทุนกับเรา สมัครเอเย่น Gclub คลิ๊กได้เลย

    ReplyDelete
  14. Excellent Post as always and you have a great post and i like it thank you for sharing


    เว็บไซต์คาสิโนออนไลน์ที่ได้คุณภาพอับดับ 1 ของประเทศ
    เป็นเว็บไซต์การพนันออนไลน์ที่มีคนมา สมัคร Gclub Royal1688
    และยังมีหวยให้คุณได้เล่น สมัครหวยออนไลน์ ได้เลย
    สมัครสมาชิกที่นี่ >>> Gclub Royal1688
    ร่วมลงทุนสมัครเอเย่นคาสิโนกับทีมงานของเราได้เลย

    ReplyDelete
  15. what do you do If someone grabs away your property, OR there is a breach of agreement of sale OR You are planning to buy a property and you wish to know if there is a claim or objection to the said land, Of course you approach an advocate. As per the situation demands he may sometimes ask you to Public Notice Ad in Newspaper. Now what do you do? you don’t want to spend thousands of rupees on Newspaper ads just for placing a legal notice but at the sometime you also want to fulfil the formality. How do we help you?

    ReplyDelete
  16. People need to know what is immigration law and how much importance. I have read a complete guide of IMMIGRATION LAWS and NATURALIZATION LAWYERS on https://adidasolsale.com/immigration-laws-naturalization-lawyers/

    ReplyDelete
  17. Today, businesses need to build trust with consumers as they like to get as much information as they can about a product or service before they move forward with the purchase. This is where 2 Way SMS - ExpertTexting comes in to boost personalized communication desired.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Delta Customer Service Number
    Delta Customer Service
    Delta Customer Number
    Delta Service Number
    +18882623768
    DELTA CUSTOMER SUPPORT AND SERVICES
    +18882623768 Delta customer number for
    Technical Support

    Reservations

    Cargo Department

    Customer Service

    Lost Baggage

    Medallion Status








    ReplyDelete
  19. Important article always good to every readers. Readers feel very happy to read every article. Thank you so much for the valuable post. You may visit Xiclassadmission in Bangladesh. Everyone can visit www xiclassadmission gov bd official website to check HSC Admission Result with simple process. All Board HSC Result 2019 also available here. Thanks again.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Thank you for sharing such a useful information.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Quickbooks Enterprise Support Phone Number
    Get Help for all your issues with QuickBooks Enterprise.
    Call (888) 802-9333
    Call Intuit QuickBooks Online Customer Services Helpline Phone Number USA 1-888-802-9333 to fix your Accounting Issues.
    QuickBooks Technical Support Contact Team Will fixes your issue Enterprises,
    Payroll, Pro, Premier, Vat, Bank Errors etc , QuickBooks Online Support Number 1-888-802-9333 USA

    ReplyDelete
  22. Awesome content uses in this blog. Visit Ogen Infosystem for the best Website Designing and Digital Marketing Services.
    Webste Design Company

    ReplyDelete
  23. HP printer has several models with different features. It is based on advanced technology, yet there is a possibility that some technical glitches might occur while using it. In that case, you have the option of HP Printer Technical Support Number +1-870-345-4464 where you will be able to rectify the error by certified technicians.
    HP Printer Customer Care Number
    HP Printer Customer service Number

    ReplyDelete
  24. +1 (888) 262-3763 Delta Airlines Customer Service Number for :

    Delta Airline Reservatations

    Airline Booking

    PNR Change

    Online Delta Ticket Booking

    Delta Customer Care

    Best phone number to reach Delta

    Airline VIP Lounge

    Delta Celebrity Reservation



    24 hours, 7 days
    Delta customer service number .
    Get in touch with Delta’s customer service department through the following phone numbers,email and contact form.
    For more information about reservations, technical support, cargo department, lost baggage and medallion status, please call the numbers listed Above .

    Delta Customer Service Number
    Delta Flight Reservation Number
    Delta Customer Service
    Delta Customer Number
    Delta Service Number
    Delta Airlines Reservation Number

    ReplyDelete
  25. Apply India EVisa from your home country Online.
    No need to visit Embassy and No more worries about document and application validation.
    Evisa India can be now applied Online by visiting i-visaindia.com
    - Click on Apply eVisa or Begin Application
    - Start filling the first form with Basic Details for applying Indian eVisa
    - Complete form 2 and form 3
    - Make Payment and Upload Documents
    -Submit Your eVisa Application.
    - Wait for Confirmation email.
    - Your evisa India is applied Successfully
    - Find your eVisa India in your email.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Great article! One of the best Tarot Reading App for Android & iPhone is Tarot Life! Download the same for free!

    ReplyDelete
  27. reinstall kaspersky with activation code- Protect your data, devices, and your family With the development of the digital world, online protection is crucial. It is extremely important to protect your PCs, Mac, computers as well as mobile devices and tablets with Kaspersky Activate. This can be done with the help of effective internet security and anti-virus products from Kaspersky Activate that safeguards all devices used on digital platforms. This antivirus program is so light and easy to install, you and your family will be protected in just moments. It’ll then keep protecting you day and night, automatically updating itself against the latest threats to help keep you and your family safe.

    ReplyDelete
  28. install webroot antivirus with key code– With the development of the digital world, online protection is crucial. It is extremely important to protect your PCs, Mac, computers as well as mobile devices and tablets with webroot com safe. This can be done with the help of effective internet security and anti-virus products from www webroot com safe that safeguards all devices used on digital platforms.

    ReplyDelete
  29. webroot.com/safe- As people all around the world carry out their everyday work on their official and personal computers, they require total security against all kinds of threats that these virus files can cause. Using webroot com safe as an anti-virus makes you feel safe and provides you the safety shields to stop malicious files from entering the Desktop, laptop, smartphone via malware, rootkit, spyware.

    ReplyDelete
  30. download webroot with key code– With the development of the digital world, online protection is crucial. It is extremely important to protect your PCs, Mac, computers as well as mobile devices and tablets with webroot.com/safe. This can be done with the help of effective internet security and anti-virus products from www.webroot.com/safe that safeguards all devices used on digital platforms.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Webroot download with key code- As people all around the world carry out their everyday work on their official and personal computers, they require total security against all kinds of threats that these virus files can cause. Using webroot.com/safe as an anti-virus makes you feel safe and provides you the safety shields to stop malicious files from entering the Desktop, laptop, smartphone via malware, rootkit, spyware.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Webroot geek squad download- With the development of the digital world, online protection is crucial. It is extremely important to protect your PCs, Mac, computers as well as mobile devices and tablets with www.webroot.com/geeksquaddownload. This can be done with the help of effective internet security and anti-virus products from www webroot com geek squad download that safeguards all devices used on digital platforms.

    ReplyDelete
  33. www.trendmicro.com/bestbuypc- Computer security is the process of preventing and detecting unauthorized use of your computer. Prevention measures help you stop unauthorized users from accessing any part of your computer system. Detection helps you to determine whether or not someone attempted to break into your system if they were successful, and what they may have done.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Trend Micro exe file download- Computer security is the process of preventing and detecting unauthorized use of your computer. Prevention measures help you stop unauthorized users from accessing any part of your computer system. Detection helps you to determine whether or not someone attempted to break into your system, if they were successful, and what they may have done.

    ReplyDelete
  35. mcafee.com/activate- The McAfee Internet Security Suite and antivirus programs are products produced by McAfee to help protect home, business, or school computers. McAfee requires a product activation for all products purchased online or from an in-store purchase. The activation feature required for McAfee products helps to minimize the negative impact of software piracy as well as to ensure your product is properly registered with the company in order to receive timely updates and news of computer malware threats that could threaten your security. Being able to activate McAfee computer security products is a common task for consumers who purchase their products.

    ReplyDelete
  36. AOL desktop gold sign in - What are you waiting for in your scheme to download and install AOL Desktop Gold and start the interesting voyage of exploring this software's unique characteristics. You can always refer to AOL Desktop Gold for all kinds of assistance where your query will be answered. This is popular with all fresh user interface characteristics and features that are now accessible and advance safety features. AOL Gold can assist you to access your messages, search for content, and even browsing. Among all web interfaces, AOL Gold is best.

    ReplyDelete
  37. AOL Desktop Gold – This is popular with all fresh user interface characteristics and features that are now accessible, and advanced safety features. AOL Gold can assist you to access your messages, search for content, and even browsing. Among all web interfaces, AOL Gold is best. What are you waiting for in your scheme to download and install AOL Desktop Gold and start the interesting voyage of exploring this software’s unique characteristics? You can always refer to AOL Desktop Gold for all kinds of assistance where your query will be answered.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Reinstall AOL gold desktop for windows 10 – This is popular with all fresh user interface characteristics and features that are now accessible, and advanced safety features. AOL Gold can assist you to access your messages, search for content, and even browsing. Among all web interfaces, AOL Gold is best. What are you waiting for in your scheme to download and install AOL Desktop Gold and start the interesting voyage of exploring this software’s unique characteristics? You can always refer to AOL Desktop Gold for all kinds of assistance where your query will be answered.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Reinstall AOL gold desktop for windows 10 – This is popular with all fresh user interface characteristics and features that are now accessible, and advanced safety features. AOL Gold can assist you to access your messages, search for content, and even browsing. Among all web interfaces, AOL Gold is best. What are you waiting for in your scheme to download and install AOL Desktop Gold and start the interesting voyage of exploring this software’s unique characteristics? You can always refer to AOL Desktop Gold for all kinds of assistance where your query will be answered.

    ReplyDelete
  40. We are popular as Florist Service in Gurgaon from last 10 Years, we also offers fresh flowers cakes and latest gifts across Gurgaon. Send flowers online and Offline from flower shop for your loved ones and availlable for corporate gifting with fastest delivery.

    Florist Service in Gurgaon
    Online Florist Services in Gurgaon

    ReplyDelete
  41. I was scrolling the internet like every day, there I found this article which is related to my interest. The way you covered the knowledge about the subject and the 2 BHK Flat in Ayodhya bypass Road was worth to read, it undoubtedly cleared my vision and thoughts towards B 4 BHK Flat in Ayodhya bypass Road. Your writing skills and the way you portrayed the examples are very impressive. The knowledge about 3 BHK Flat in Ayodhya bypass Road is well covered. Thank you for putting this highly informative article on the internet which is clearing the vision about top builders in Bhopal and who are making an impact in the real estate sector by building such amazing townships.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Probably it will provide a little bit relief to the Ld. Presiding Officers of the Commercial Court

    ReplyDelete
  43. Informative blog, get the best Mutual Fund Companies and Investment Advisor in Delhi at Mutualfundwala.
    Mutual Fund Companies

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...