![]() |
Justice Ganguly Supreme Court of India |
The Supreme Court in Maharashtra University of Health and others v. Satchikitsa Prasarak Mandal & Others has examined and explained the meaning of 'Ejusdem Generis' as a rule of interpretation of statutes in our legal system. While examining the doctrine, the Supreme Court held as under;
26. The Latin expression “ejusdem generis” which means “of the same kind or nature” is a principle of construction, meaning thereby when general words in a statutory text are flanked by restricted words, the meaning of the general words are taken to be restricted by implication with the meaning of restricted words. This is a principle which arises “from the linguistic implication by which words having literally a wide meaning (when taken in isolation) are treated as reduced in scope by the verbal context.” It may be regarded as an instance of ellipsis, or reliance on implication. This principle is presumed to apply unless there is some contrary indication (See Glanville Williams, ‘The Origins and Logical Implications of the Ejusdem Generis Rule’ 7 Conv (NS) 119).
27. This ejusdem generis principle is a facet of the principle of Noscitur a sociis. The Latin maxim Noscitur a sociis contemplates that a statutory term is recognised by its associated words. The Latin word ‘sociis’ means ‘society’. Therefore, when general words are juxtaposed with specific words, general words cannot be read in isolation. Their colour and their contents are to be derived from their context [See similar observations of Viscount Simonds in Attorney General v. Prince Ernest Augustus of Hanover, (1957) AC 436 at 461 of the report]
28. But like all other linguistic canons of construction, the ejusdem generis principle applies only when a contrary intention does not appear. In instant case, a contrary intention is clearly indicated inasmuch as the definition of ‘teachers’ under Section 2(35) of the said Act, as pointed out above, is in two parts. The first part deals with enumerated categories but the second part which begins by the expression “and other” envisages a different category of persons. Here ‘and’ is disjunctive. So, while construing such a definition the principle of ejusdem generis cannot be applied.
29. In this context, we should do well to remember the caution sounded by Lord Scarman in Quazi v. Quazi – [(1979) 3 All-England Reports 897]. At page 916 of the report, the learned Law Lord made this pertinent observation:- “If the legislative purpose of a statute is such that a statutory series should be read ejusdem generis, so be it; the rule is helpful. But, if it is not, the rule is more likely to defeat than to fulfil the purpose of the statute. The rule, like many other rules of statutory interpretation, is a useful servant but a bad master.”
30. This Court while construing the principle of ejusdem generis laid down similar principles in the case of K.K. Kochuni v. State of Madras and Kerala, [AIR 1960 SC 1080]. A Constitution Bench of this Court in Kochuni (supra) speaking through Justice Subba Rao (as His Lordship then was) at paragraph 50 at page 1103 of the report opined:-
“...The rule is that when general words follow particular and specific words of the same nature, the general words must be confined to the things of the same kind as those specified. But it is clearly laid down by decided cases that the specific words must form a distinct genus or category. It is not an inviolable rule of law, but is only permissible inference in the absence of an indication to the contrary.”
31. Again this Court in another Constitution Bench decision in the case of Amar Chandra Chakraborty v. The Collector of Excise, Govt. of Tripura, Agartala and others, AIR 1972 SC 1863, speaking through Justice Dua, reiterated the same principles in paragraph 9, at page 1868 of the report. On the principle of ejusdem generis, the learned Judge observed as follows:-
“…The ejusdem generis rule strives to reconcile the incompatibility between specific and general words. This doctrine applies when (i) the statute contains an enumeration of specific words; (ii) the subjects of the enumeration constitute a class or category; (iii) that class or category is not exhausted by the enumeration; (iv) the general term follows the enumeration; and (v) there is no indication of a different legislative intent.”
32. As noted above, in the instant case, there is a statutory indication to the contrary. Therefore, where there is statutory indication to the contrary the definition of teacher under Section 2(35) cannot be read on the basis of ejusdem generis nor can the definition be confined to only approved teachers. If that is done, then a substantial part of the definition under Section 2(35) would become redundant. That is against the very essence of the doctrine of ejusdem generis. The purpose of this doctrine is to reconcile any incompatibility between specific and general words so that all words in a Statute can be given effect and no word becomes superfluous (See Sutherland: Statutory Construction, 5th Edition, page 189, Volume 2A).
33. It is also one of the cardinal canons of construction that no Statute can be interpreted in such a way as to render a part of it otiose.
34. It is, therefore, clear where there is a different legislative intent, as in this case, the principle of ejusdem generis cannot be applied to make a part of the definition completely redundant.
35. By giving such a narrow and truncated interpretation of `teachers' under Section 2(35), High court has not only ignored a part of Section 2(35) but it has also unfortunately given an interpretation which is incompatible with the avowed purpose of Section 53 of the Act.
Sir! thankyou so much . Your Article has helped me in understanding wht ejusdem generis means. i will definately write these cases and illustrations in my LLM interpretation exam.
ReplyDeleteregards
ADV.Bhavneet
Nice post!! Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteDermology anti aging Serum
dermology anti aging cream
Dermology
dermology hair removal cream
dermology hair removal cream
dermology hair removal cream
dermology cellulite reduction cream
Xtreme No
Xtremeno
hgh energizer
Xtrmly amazimg...... soo clearly and simply defined
ReplyDeleteXtrmly amazimg...... soo clearly and simply defined
ReplyDeleteVery precise and clear information
ReplyDeletechampions trophy schedule 2017
ReplyDeletecpl schedule 2017
icc women wc schedule 2017
salman khan upcoming movies
shah rukh khan upcoming movies
tubelight collection
Dua for Love and Attraction in Couples, ” Dua for Love and Attraction in Couples , ” As Salamu ‘Alaykum to all my lovely people who are reading this. Today, I would like to throw a light on a healthier married life in Islam. Dua for Any Wish Hajat to Come True Dua for Any Wish Hajat to Come True , ” In this perishable world, there are millions of people who have their own millions of wishes. Wishes mean so much for them. Some need money, some need the home, some need to ease their financial hardships and some want to
ReplyDeleteTaweez for Making Someone Love YouTaweez for Making Someone Love You , ” If you want some one to fall in love with you but you dont want to to do long wazaif or wazaif to recite daily, then this is the taweez for you, On the first Thursday of the moon write this taweez
Kisi ko Wapas Pane ka Wazifa Ager aap ka piyar aap sey bichar gaya hai waja chahye jo bhi aur aap usey k bagher jiney ka tasawor bhi nahi kersaktey, aur usey her surat men wapis hasil kerna chahtey han tu Kisi ko Wapas Pane ka Wazifa aap k liye hi hai, Ye wazifa larka aur larki
Narazgi Khatam Karne Ka Wazifa Ager aap sey koi kisi bhi baat per naraz hogaya hai tu usey mananey men pahel karen is ka bohet ajr o sawab hai, aur hadees men ata hai k 3 din sey zada narazgi sahi nahi, tu Narazgi Khatam Karne k liye 21 bar ” Ya Maniu ” sobha aur
Wazifa To Make Parents Agree For Love Marriage
Pyar Mein Pagal Karne Ka Wazifa
Powerful Dua For Pleasing Husband
Wazifa To Create Love Someone Heart
mpsc current affairs
ReplyDeletebox office collection
shayari hindi
marathi news paper
happy raksha bandhan quotes
ReplyDeleterakhi quotes
raksha bandhan 2017
raksha bandhan sms
happy raksha bandhan wishes
raksha bandhan messages
happy raksha bandhan sms
raksha bandhan wishes
ReplyDeleteraksha bandhan status
raksha bandhan images
rakhi images
independence day speeches
independence day quotes in hindi
independence day quotes in english
nice post
ReplyDeletejudwaa 2 collection
judwaa 2 box office collection
isl 2017 live score
judwaa 2 box office collection
isl live score 2017
isl 2017 live streaming
Fantastic exposition
ReplyDeletejust information we only provide information for those who need it
ReplyDeleteNice Post thanks for sharing with us.... If you have any query related Apple device so contact Apple customer care number
ReplyDeleteReset Apple ID Password | Apple ID Password Reset | Reset apple password | Apple Password Reset | Forgot Apple ID Password | Recover Apple Password | Change Apple Id Password | Apple ID Password Recovery | I forgot my apple id password | Apple ID Support | if you forgot your apple id password | apple id disabled | how to find my apple id? | lost apple id password and recovery key | Reset Apple ID | Lost Apple ID | I forgot my Apple password how can i get it back | How to recover your Apple ID password | forgot my apple id | Not Remember an Apple ID | Apple Id Not Working | How To Reset Apple Id Password | how to change apple id password
https://www.applemacbookprocare.com/reset-apple-id-password-australia/
ReplyDeleteWe can resize the photo with the help of Adobe Photoshop Editing service. We make cropping, positioning and file size optimization for nearly all the images we process.By carrying out these processes in a line the images are 100% ready for final use. Image Cropping By saving images in the final format and with the right compression long loading time is ignored.If you are looking for the best Image resizing or cropping service Provider then contact us immediately.
Nice post and thanks for sharing this blog.
ReplyDeletedownload aol desktop gold
install aol desktop gold
aol desktop gold download
download AOL Desktop Gold Software
download AOL Desktop Gold Software
download aol gold
install aol gold
download aol gold software
install aol gold desktop
aol desktop gold
aol gold desktop download
install aol gold desktop for windows 10
aol gold desktop download for windows 10
reinstall AOL desktop gold windows 10
aol gold program download
free aol gold desktop 9.7 download
download aol gold 9.7 desktop
aol gold software download
aol gold contact number
aol gold software
Such a nice post thanks for sharing with us.. If you have any issues regarding AOL Desktop gold so just contact
ReplyDeleteDownload AOL Desktop Gold | Download AOL Gold | Install AOL Desktop Gold | Install AOL Gold | Download AOL Desktop Gold Software | AOL Gold Download Link | AOL Desktop Gold Download | AOL Desktop Gold Software | Reinstall AOL Desktop Gold | Download AOL Gold Software | Update AOL Gold | Install AOL Desktop Gold Software | Install AOL Gold Software | Download AOL Desktop Gold | AOL Desktop Gold support number | AOL Desktop Gold Technical support | AOL Desktop Gold customer support | AOL Desktop Gold Login | AOL Gold Sign in | Download AOL Desktop Gold for windows 10 | Latest AOL gold software | AOL desktop gold | Free AOL Gold Desktop 9.7 Download | Download AOL Gold 9.7 Desktop | AOL Gold | AOL Gold Support Number | install aol gold desktop on mac os x | AOL gold login | AOL gold upgrade | AOL desktop gold for mac | AOL desktop gold upgrade
Nice Post thanks for sharing with us....For more informattion click here-
ReplyDeletecomcast password reset
forgot comcast password
reset comcast password
recover comcast password
reset comcast email password
recover comcast email password
reset comcast mail password
forgot comcast email password
frontier password reset
forgot frontier password
reset frontier password
recover frontier password
reset frontier email password
recover frontier email password
reset frontier mail password
forgot frontier email password
aol password reset
forgot aol password
reset aol password
recover aol password
reset aol email password
recover aol email password
reset aol mail password
forgot aol email password
Brighthouse password reset
forgot Brighthouse password
reset Brighthouse password
recoverBrighthouse password
recover Brighthouse password
reset Brighthouse email password
recover Brighthouse email password
reset Brighthouse mail password
forgot Brighthouse email password
ReplyDeleteNice Post thanks for sharing with us.... If you have any query related printer device so contact
Printer support number
Printer phone number
Printer contact number
Printer helpline number
Printer support phone number
Printer customer care
Printer customer support
Printer customer service
Printer technical support
Printer tech support
Printer customer care number
Printer customer support number
Printer customer service number
Printer technical support number
Printer tech support number
Thanks for giving the information it is useful.to know further activation key please read:
ReplyDeletenorton activation key
norton product key
norton product activation Key
norton activation key support
activation key for norton
norton activation
norton activate
norton com setup
norton product activation
norton com setup activation
avast activation key
avast product key
avast product activation Key
avast activation key support
activation key for avast
avast activation
avast activate
how to activate avast
avast product activation
avast com setup activation
avg activation key
avg product key
avg product activation Key
avg activation key support
activation key for avg
avg activation
avg activate
how to activate avg
avg product activation
avg com setup activation
This is very informative and intresting.Those who need any help regarding SBC global please visit:
ReplyDeletesbcglobal support
sbcglobal helpline number
sbcglobal phone number
sbcglobal contact number
sbcglobal support number
sbcglobal customer care
sbcglobal customer service
sbcglobal customer support
sbcglobal tech support
sbcglobal technical support
sbcglobal customer care number
sbcglobal customer service number
sbcglobal customer support number
sbcglobal tech support number
sbcglobal technical support number
Great Article blockchain projects for students
ReplyDeleteIEEE Projects for Engineering Students
JavaScript Training in Chennai
Networking Projects
JavaScript Training in Chennai